back to top
IndiaSC flags issue of ‘Pick & Choose’ by Centre in clearing names...

SC flags issue of ‘Pick & Choose’ by Centre in clearing names recommended by Collegium for transfer of judges


NEW DELHI, Nov 20: The Supreme Court on Monday flagged the issue of “pick and choose” by the Centre in clearing the Collegium's recommendations for transferring high court judges and said this does not send a good signal.

The court observed that of the 11 names of judges recommended by the collegium for transfer, five have been transferred but six are still pending — four from the Gujarat High Court and one each from the high courts of Allahabad and Delhi.

A bench of Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Sudhanshu Dhulia said of the recently-recommended names for judgeship in high courts, eight have not been cleared and some of these judges are senior to those who have been appointed.

“As per my information, you have issued transfer orders for five judges. For six judges, you have not issued. Four of them are from Gujarat. Last time also, I had said this does not send a good signal,” Justice Kaul, who is also a member of the apex court collegium, told Attorney General R Venkataramani.

Asserting that this as not acceptable, the judge said, “Last time also, I did emphasise that don't do selective transfers. It creates its own dynamics.”

Observing that the government is following a “pick and choose” policy regarding the names recommended by the collegium for transfers, the bench said, “Just look at it. What is the signal you are sending?”

The bench was hearing two petitions, including one alleging a delay on the Centre's part in clearing the names recommended by the collegium for appointment and transfer of judges.

During the hearing, the top court said a problem arises when selective appointment takes place as people lose their seniority.

“Why will people agree to become judges?” it asked, adding, “This is something on which we had commented earlier that if a candidate does not know what seniority he would stand as a judge, it becomes difficult to persuade other eligible and deserving candidates.”

It also referred to some older recommendations made by the collegium and said it included names that have either been reiterated once or twice.

The bench observed that there cannot be a scenario where other names are stopped if the government does not clear one name from those recommended by the collegium.

It said three names were recommended in July where the expected timeline was over for the names to be sent back to the collegium with inputs.

Venkataramani said as far as the reiterated names are concerned, there has been progress. He requested the bench to take up the matter after a week or 10 days and said several things are getting cleared.

The apex court posted the matter for further hearing on December 5.

During the hearing, the bench referred to an issue concerning the and High Court and said two senior persons, whose names were recommended, have not been appointed yet.

It noted that of the remaining 11 names, where the judges had to be shifted from one court to another, five have been transferred, but six transfers are still pending.

The bench also recorded in its order that in the Gauhati High Court, the name of one of the senior candidates was not cleared at the first instance and the issue was taken up on a very serious note.

It said ultimately, the oath of others was delayed for some time to facilitate the government to issue the warrant of appointment for that person.


The Northlines is an independent source on the Web for news, facts and figures relating to Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh and its neighbourhood.

Share post:


More like this

Women make up less than 10 pc of Lok Sabha poll candidates: ADR

New Delhi, May 22: Less than 10 per cent...

RBI transfers record Rs 2.11 lakh crore dividend to government

MUMBAI, May 22: The Reserve Bank of India will...

“On June 4, People Will Wake Them From Their Sleep”: PM Modi Takes Dig At Opposition At Rally In Basti

Basti (Uttar Pradesh), May 22: Prime Minister Narendra Modi...

Army Doesn’t Want Agniveer Scheme, India Bloc Govt Will Throw It In Dustbin: Rahul

MAHENDRAGARH (Haryana), May 22: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said...