back to top
OpinionsOpen letter to Rahul Gandhi on OROP issue

Open letter to Rahul Gandhi on OROP issue


Open to Rahul Gandhi on OROP issue

Rajeev Chandrashekhar

I had first written to you on the issue way back in 2011, but you neither replied to it nor took any action.

Dear Rahul,

Most Indians are anguished about the sad and tragic suicide of veteran subedar Ram Kishan Grewal of 105 Inf Btn TA and DSC. I suspect you were trying to convey your deep feeling and concern by visiting the family of the Veteran at Ram Manohar Lohia hospital along with an entourage shouting “Rahul Gandhi ki Jai”.

However, may I respectfully suggest that going with an entourage shouting “Rahul Gandhi ki Jai” to a hospital full of patients and worrying relatives may not be the best way to show your recently discovered concern for veterans.

I say recently discovered because you and your successive UPA government's actions and conduct on One Rank, One Pension (OROP) are there in the public domain and worth reiterating.

Let me jog your memory, while I have raised the demand for OROP since I stepped into Parliament in 2006, it was during the terms of Congress led UPA-1 and UPA -2 that I wrote several letters to and had several meetings on the matter with the then prime minister, minister, chairperson UPA and also to you urging for implementation of the long pending OROP.

All of them were met with either a “can't do it” or a stony silence. There was even a Parliamentary committee of Petitions under Shri Koshiyari that studied a petition that I was instrumental in submitting and even its report submitted in 2011 was ignored by the UPA government.

I had first written to you on OROP and other armed forces related issues way back in 2011, but you neither replied to it nor took any action. It probably wasn't politically “interesting” enough for you then. It took you years to even mention and get to that issue – and even then it was only before elections 2014 as a pre-poll election stunt. It was then I wrote to you in February 2014 where I lauded your belated interest, reminding you of how belated it was with a list of all my letters written to then prime minister, defence minister, Congress chairperson and yourself requesting you to address the serious issue and prevent further alienation and disenchantment in the veteran community. (Letter enclosed).

Even when the OROP was hurriedly announced by your government prior to elections, adding insult to injury was your minister allocating a mere Rs 500 crore – a cruel joke which would not have been enough for enhanced pensions for even ten per cent of the veterans.

It took the current government, despite serious objections from the finance ministry about the fiscal implications, to announce and implement OROP – costing almost Rs 8,300 crore per annum and a onetime cost of more than Rs 20,000 crore – correcting a four-decade old injustice perpetrated on our veterans.

Because, as its worth reminding you, in 1972-73 it was Indira Gandhi, then prime minister who in one stroke terminated OROP after the 1971 India-Pakistan war. In 2002, Congress president Sonia Gandhi spoke and advocated for OROP at a political rally, but then followed it up with being in power until 2014 and not having it implemented.

The Congress in 2004 even included the OROP in its manifesto promising a solution, but spent the entire term and then the next denying the same to the veterans.

Perhaps you also need to be reminded that in 2008 the then defence minister AK Antony stated that the UPA government had not found the OROP demand acceptable! The UPA government, had rejected the OROP demand, holding that it would be a huge financial cost of over Rs 3,500 crore then.

When I joined the veterans in their protest in December 2008 as they sat for a relay fast at Jantar Mantar or when the veterans marched to Rashtrapati Bhawan in 2009 surrendering their medals to the president for non-implementation of OROP, I do not recall you or anyone in your party saying a word in support or doing anything about it.

You may want to be reminded that it was this refusal to implement OROP by the Congress-led UPA government that led me to facilitate a petition by citizens and Veterans to the Committee of Petitions, Rajya Sabha that resulted in the Koshiyari Committee report of 2011, tabled in Parliament only to have your UPA government respond thus – “Not possible because administrative, financial and legal complications in implementation of the OROP scheme.”

My repeated letters and interventions in Parliament continued through the regime of Congress-led UPA-1 and UPA-2 and never once do I recall you showing solidarity with the struggle of the veterans. In August 2010, I declined to accepted the salary hike given to MP's until the OROP issue was settled completely.

There's much to be reminded of on the larger aspect of welfare of armed forces and veterans – like the UPA government's track record on welfare and key issues like – lack of voting rights for armed forces, lack of adequate housing for serving forces and families etc or maybe these are issues that are not currently politically interesting enough.

Rahul – I accept the premise that yours may be a case of belated wisdom and compassion dawning. That is a good thing. But it's a bit trite to assume that past records of political parties will be forgotten and that the country doesn't realise how far we have come in the cause of serving and repaying our veterans in the past two years compared to the past four decades.

Yes, there are some pending complex issues in OROP including some fundamental issues to ensure consistency with the definition of One Rank, One Pension.

These were referred to the One Man Judicial Committee set up to look after these anomalies. This committee has only recently submitted its report and we should look to them.

The death of subedar Grewal is a terrible blot on a nation that takes pride in its armed forces and the tradition of service and sacrifice they represent. It is indisputable that over the past several decades, the defence ministry and bureaucracy have become apathetic and uncaring to the plight of our veterans, widows and serving forces and their families.

There is no doubt that this needs changing and transforming and that must be where the genuine political anger if any must be focussed. Grandstanding and political opportunism tends to stale rapidly and hypocrisy even faster.


Rajeev Chandrashekhar

Member of Parliament & Entrepreneur .

The Northlines is an independent source on the Web for news, facts and figures relating to Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh and its neighbourhood.

Share post:


More like this

Elder abuse remains an underreported crisis

There is a pressing need for unified and comprehensive...

President Putin interested in improving relations with ASEAN through Vietnam

By Girish Linganna After visiting North Korea, Russian President Vladimir...

When One Dares a PM for Public Debate

by Dr. Jaipal Singh This author has been watching this opposition...

Finance Ministry’s decision to impose a fine on Binance is a step in right direction

  Indian regulators have to strictly monitor Crypto-Currency companies By Arun...