back to top
    OpinionsIndia's defence is backward and unequipped when compared to China

    India’s defence is backward and unequipped when compared to China


    India's is backward and unequipped when compared to China

    Claude Arpi

    It is high time for the Indian military to seriously embark on its long march to modernisation.

    China has a dream: to ensure economic prosperity, social stability, and a decent life to its citizens, but also to become a powerful nation; in fact it dreams to become one day the most powerful nation on the planet.

    Military power will play a crucial role in the rejuvenation of the Chinese nation. This explains the in-depth military reforms undertaken by President Xi Jinping a year ago.

    China is really serious about this. On December 5 in Beijing, President Xi Jinping, who is also chairman of the Central Military Commission (CMC) attended a two-day meeting during which he called for “a smaller army with better combat capability and optimised structure.”


    Xi spoke about the informationised modern warfare and emphasised the importance of joint operations. He called for readjusting and optimising the military's structure: “new type of forces must be developed, the ratios between different types of forces must be rationalised, and the number and the scale of the military be downsized.”

    This raises two important questions. While undertaking these reforms, has China not taken a too large bite, which is now difficult to chew? The other question is: what does this mean for India?

    Xinhua remarked that December 2015 “marked a fresh start in the history of the Chinese Armed Forces, as the nation embarked on a long march of deepening military reform.” On December 31, new services were created, namely, the PLA Army, the PLA Rocket Force and the PLA Strategic Support Force, and a few weeks later, the seven erstwhile Military Regions were regrouped into five PLA Theater Commands.

    The creation of a PLA Strategic Support Force is a plunge into the future as it will deal with cyber and space warfare, probably the keys of tomorrow's conflicts. But changing mindsets and controlling vested interests is not an easy proposition.

    Peter Wood, the editor of the China Brief of the Jamestown Foundation noted that Chinese publications “calling for the PLA to ‘cast off' old concepts about the predominance of the ground forces are further indication that the transition has not gone smoothly.”

    Regarding India: it is high time India undertakes reforms, in which the role of the ground forces (Indian Army) need to be rebalanced with the Navy and the Air Force, giving a greater role to “informationised warfare”.

    There are other issues which need to be reviewed: take for example the appointment of a Chief of Defence Staff (CDS). In December 2015, defence minister Manohar Parrikar said that the post of CDS “could be a reality soon”. He then added that the prime minister “marked defence reforms as a priority and stressed that ‘jointness at the top' was a need long overdue.”


    The CDS would coordinate between the three services, the strategic command responsible for the nuclear weapons…and one day, the cyber and space commands. The creation of a post of CDS was already recommended by a Group of Ministers in 2001.

    But what happened since then? Practically nothing.

    Another example of the apathy of the Indian system is the Indian Defence University (INDU). Planned since decades, the government finally approved the setting up of the INDU at an estimated cost of 2.95 billion in in 2010.

    On the occasion of the laying of the foundation stone by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in 2013, Air Chief Marshal NAK Browne, the then chairman of the chiefs of staff committee asserted that “India needs military leaders who can critically analyse, demonstrate professional acumen and are capable of meeting the threats and challenges at the tactical, operational and strategic levels.”

    What has happened to the INDU? Lost in the corridors of South Block?

    In the meantime, Kanwa Asian Defense, a Chinese-language publication reported that China's military build-up is coming closer to India.


    Beijing's military would have placed more missiles and fighter jets along the Indian border: “The weapons have been deployed in Tibet and in the western region of Xinjiang along with airborne early warning and control systems.”

    Kanwa said that Chinese troops have placed the J-11, the J-10 and the Kongjing-500 (airborne early warning and control or AEW&C aircraft) in rotational deployment. The Shenyang J-11 is a twin-engine jet fighter, developed to compete with fourth-generation fighters.

    On December 3, 2016, a PLA website showed pictures of airmen “assigned to an aviation regiment under the PLA Western Theater Command performing flight checks on a J-11 fighter jet prior to a round-the-clock flight training exercise under realistic combat at a military airfield.” The airport is located near the Indian border.

    Kanwa also said that in Korla (Xinjiang), China may have deployed troops for the launch of mid-range ballistic missiles and in Hotan, north of the Aksai Chin, J-10 and H-6K strategic bomber would have been spotted.

    Is it not high time for the Indian defence forces to seriously embark on its long march to modernisation?

    (Courtesy of Mail Today.)

    The Northlines is an independent source on the Web for news, facts and figures relating to Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh and its neighbourhood.

    Share post:


    More like this

    UNION BUDGET 2024: Implications for Indian Agriculture

    Dr. Parveen Kumar The Union Budget 2024 presented in the...

    Dr.Vishwas Brings legends alive

    Vinod Chandra shekhar  Dixit Recently inDungarpur (Rajasthan) on the occasion of...

    Kamala Harris Is A Desi At Heart

    ‘I think of that young baby, still in her...

    West Bengal’s Potato decision escalates tensions with north-eastern states

      By Arun Kumar Shrivastav West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's...